Citizenship Trial: Court asks Defence to Specify its Objections

Header Image

The defence cites legal privilege, protection of communications and the legality of the seizure of electronic data. The case will resume on 23 November 2026.

 

The Nicosia Criminal Court on Monday asked the defence to specify its objections concerning documents and electronic data seized from the law firm of defendant 9. The proceedings are part of the citizenship-by-investment trial, in which former Transport Minister Marios Demetriades is among the accused.

The defence had sought a single “trial within a trial” to examine its objections concerning legal professional privilege, the protection of communications, the legality of obtaining the exhibits and their relevance to the indictment.

Lawyer Elias Stefanou presented four main grounds of objection concerning exhibits collected during the execution of three search warrants at the offices of defendant 9 between 29 and 31 July 2021. The items seized included, among other things, mobile phones, computer towers, hard drives, memory sticks and physical files containing documents.

Stefanou referred in particular to exhibit 231, a hard drive containing all the data obtained from hard drives and mobile phones.

Multiple objections

The first objection, he said, concerns protected communications and legal professional privilege belonging to defendant 9 and her lawyers in electronic data from servers, hard drives and mobile phones. As an example, he said exhibit 231 contains a communication between him and defendant 3 about the current court proceedings, made during the searches.

The second objection concerns alleged breaches of the terms of the search warrants and orders authorising access to communications during their execution. “Our position is that the instructions of the judges who authorised access to the law office of defendant 9, as well as the orders for access to communications, were one thing, while the investigators’ actions in obtaining exhibits and electronic communications were different and in breach of those authorisations,” Mr Stefanou said. He added that the legal basis of the objection rests on the Constitution, the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union and the principle of proportionality.

The third objection, he said, concerns an alleged breach of the constitutional right to communicate of defendants 3, 4 and 5. He argued that the exhibits the prosecution seeks to introduce include protected communications covered by Article 17 of the Constitution and Articles 7, 8 and 52 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights.

Impasse

The lawyer argued that the Police accessed, extracted and stored all electronic communication data held in the cloud, without limiting the search to data that might relate to the corruption offence under investigation. “The Police had no right to access, extract and store all electronic data indiscriminately,” he said, adding that any other evidence falls outside the scope of the authorising orders and is irrelevant to the prosecution.

The fourth objection concerns the relevance of the documents and exhibits the prosecution seeks to present to the Court. Stefanou said that “the investigator’s ability to take an exhibit for investigative purposes is one thing, and submitting the entire exhibit to the Court is another”. According to the defence, much of the material relates to private life, protected communications and legal professional privilege, and is unrelated to the trial.

For the prosecution, Haris Karaolidou argued that, before the Court can order a “trial within a trial”, the defendants’ objections must be clear and identify specifically the grounds on which their arguments will be based. She said the grounds must be understandable to both the prosecution and the Court; otherwise, the process could reach an impasse and place the prosecution at a disadvantage.

Nine million emails

On relevance, she disagreed that it should be examined in the same context as the legality of obtaining the exhibits. She argued that “the relevance of an exhibit cannot be the subject of a trial within a trial”, but should be considered by the Court in a different context, and described the objection as premature. If the Court rules on the legality of obtaining the exhibits in the “trial within a trial”, she added, an objection to their relevance could be raised afterwards.

On legal professional privilege, Karaolidou said the Court had not been presented with the contents of exhibit 231. She also noted that the lawyer-client relationship, when intended to facilitate the commission of a criminal offence, and related communications are not privileged, and that the Court can accept the relevant evidence.

After a break, the Court put questions to the defence, asking Stefanou to identify precisely which communications he considered protected by legal professional privilege and where he believed the terms of the court orders had been breached.

Stefanou referred to the huge volume of electronic data, saying it amounted to nine million emails. This, he said, made it extremely difficult to identify individually the communications to which the defence was referring. He also gave figures for the seized material: 1,400 messages between defendants, 198,000 emails with clients of the law firm, 800 client meetings and 149,814 photographs.

He further argued that the data included information about private life and communications unrelated to the case. The Court insisted that the objections be specified and indicated that, if each item could not be identified individually, the material being challenged should at least be categorised.

Ten defendants

The defence said it would categorise the items to which it maintained objections and asked for time to return with a more specific position. Proceedings were adjourned to allow it to identify and categorise the disputed material. The case was set to continue on 23 November 2026 at 09:30.

Ten defendants are charged in the case, eight individuals and two legal entities, including Marios Demetriades. They face various charges, including influence peddling, bribery, corruption, conspiracy to defraud, conspiracy, offences relating to VAT fraud, money laundering and breach of the Council of Europe Criminal Law Convention on Corruption.

In addition to Marios Demetriades, the accused are Andreas Demetriades, Dimitris Demetriades, George Demetriades, Eleni Symmilidi, Jing Wang, Josef Friedrich Santin, Vasiliki Georgiou-Santin, and the companies Andreas Demetriades & Co LLC and Delsk (Cyprus) Business Services Ltd.

All defendants are presumed innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt by the Court.

Source: CNA