Lawyer Appeals €10,000 Disciplinary Fine Over Comment About Student

Header Image

The lawyer has filed an appeal citing 50 grounds, challenging the complaint by 10 colleagues and questioning the impartiality of the disciplinary panel.

A lawyer fined €10,000 by the Cyprus Bar Association's Disciplinary Board over a social media comment about a student's appearance has appealed against both his conviction and the penalty imposed. The appeal, which sets out 50 grounds, challenges the basis of the complaint, the findings of the disciplinary proceedings and the impartiality of the panel.

The lawyer argues that the 10 colleagues who filed the complaint had no legitimate legal interest in doing so and alleges that their actions were motivated by personal hostility and revenge. He also questions the conduct of the Disciplinary Board's president, citing a remark allegedly made during a hearing that he claims demonstrated bias against him.

The original social media comment

The case dates back to 14 September 2021, when the lawyer represented the Paphos Bar Association at the inauguration of the Paphos School Board's new building.

During the event, which included an artistic programme featuring a student, the lawyer published a social media post expressing dissatisfaction with her choice of clothing.

In the post, he wrote:

"Really, there are some things that bother me. Tonight in Paphos, at an event held for the inauguration of the new building of the Paphos School Board, in the presence of the Metropolitan of Paphos, the Mayor of Paphos and the Minister of Education, with songs by Mikis Theodorakis, our girl came to sing wearing her little thong under her white dress... And I wonder. She decided to come dressed as she was. Was there not one person, just one person, to tell her that this was not appropriate attire for this event? Not one? I was genuinely left speechless."

The post prompted widespread reactions, following which the lawyer deleted it.

The disciplinary proceedings were initiated after a complaint was submitted by 10 lawyers from Paphos, rather than by the schoolgirl herself, her parents or her school. Only two of the 10 complainants eventually testified before the Disciplinary Board.

Appeal challenges the complainants' legal standing

One of the main grounds of appeal concerns the identity of those who filed the complaint.

The lawyer argues that his 10 colleagues had no legitimate legal interest in initiating disciplinary proceedings because the publication did not concern them personally. On that basis, he maintains that the Disciplinary Board should not have examined their complaint.

He also attributes personal and retaliatory motives to the complainants, alleging that their actions formed part of an attempt to undermine him.

In his appeal, he states that the complaint was submitted after he had already deleted the post. He maintains that his intention was to criticise those responsible for supervising the event and allowing the student to appear in the way she did.

He further argues that no individual or organisation had filed a separate complaint against him and that no civil or criminal proceedings had been initiated over the publication.

"The obvious question therefore arises: why was the complaint made? And, of course, what cannot be overlooked is that my post was entirely truthful. I am being accused because I recorded the truth," he states in his appeal.

Lawyer argues disciplinary misconduct was not established

The appellant also challenges the substance of the disciplinary conviction.

He argues that the Disciplinary Board did not explain which elements of his publication made it offensive, sexist or degrading to anyone's personality.

He further maintains that no evidence was presented to establish that the post had been published in bad faith or that his description of the student's appearance was inaccurate.

The lawyer also defends his use of the word "thong", arguing that the term is neither offensive nor immoral nor, in his view, sexist.

On this basis, he disputes whether the wording used in the publication could establish the disciplinary offence for which he was convicted.

No name or photograph of the schoolgirl published

Another argument raised in the appeal concerns the fact that the lawyer did not identify the student by name or publish a photograph of her.

He argues that his comments were not intended as a personal attack against her but were directed at those responsible for supervising the event, whom he believed had allowed her to appear inappropriately.

This forms part of his broader argument that the publication should be understood as criticism of the event's organisers rather than an attack on the schoolgirl herself.

Impartiality of the Disciplinary Board questioned

The appeal also raises concerns about the impartiality of the three members of the Disciplinary Board, all of whom are lawyers.

The appellant argues that he was not heard by an impartial body and refers to the minutes of a hearing held on 18 March 2025.

Specifically, he cites page 146 of the minutes, where he says he accused the Disciplinary Board's president of being obsessive and hostile towards him.

According to the lawyer, the president responded: "...there are many psychological issues".

The appellant argues that the remark was directed personally at him and demonstrates prejudice on the president's part.

He also points out that the other two members of the Disciplinary Board remained silent and did not distance themselves from the president's position.

Reference to third-party comments in disciplinary decision

The lawyer also questions the inclusion of comments posted by third parties beneath his original social media publication in the Disciplinary Board's decision.

He specifically refers to a comment in which he was described as a "paedophile."

In his appeal, he expresses surprise that the Disciplinary Board included the remark in its decision and questions why it did so without, he argues, providing any explanation for its inclusion.

The appeal challenges both the disciplinary finding and the €10,000 fine imposed on the lawyer. The 50 grounds set out in the appeal include objections to the complaint, the assessment of the evidence and the conduct of the disciplinary proceedings.